For most small businesses selling on their own website, Stripe is the better primary processor: its standard card rate is lower, its checkout can sit inside your site, and it handles subscriptions and invoices in one account. PayPal earns a place next to it as a button, because many buyers already trust it and use PayPal or Venmo. I build business websites for a living, and the processor decision is one I want settled before design starts, because it shapes the checkout page, the budget and the way money reaches you.
TL;DR
- Fees: Stripe lists 2.9% + 30¢ per domestic card payment. PayPal Checkout lists 3.49% + 49¢. On a $100 sale that is $3.20 versus $3.98.
- Best fit: Stripe for your own website, subscriptions, invoices and custom checkout. PayPal for buyers who want to pay with their PayPal or Venmo account, and for stores that need a ready-made button.
- Risk: Both can hold funds or close an account under their own policies, so keep your records clean and don’t depend on one account alone.
- Both together: Offering Stripe cards plus a PayPal button is common, but it means two dashboards, two support teams and more bookkeeping.
- Website: Choose before you build. The processor decides how your checkout looks and what it costs to set up.
Table of Contents
- What each one actually is
- Fees: what you pay on a $100 sale
- Checkout and customization
- Subscriptions, invoices and getting paid
- Holds, reserves and account closures
- Which one fits your business
- Using both
- How to decide in four steps
- Plan the checkout with your website
- FAQ
- Sources
What each one actually is
Stripe describes itself as financial infrastructure for accepting payments, business banking and custom revenue models. In practice that means a toolkit. Your website developer connects it to your site, and the customer pays without leaving your pages if you want it that way.
PayPal is an online payment system where people send and receive money by linking a card, a bank account or a PayPal balance. For a merchant, it is mostly a recognizable button. The buyer logs in, pays with a stored method and comes back to your site.
The analyst framing from Ecommerce Paradise is useful: Stripe is a toolkit for custom checkout, PayPal is a wallet button with a built-in buyer base. You are choosing between control and buyer familiarity.

Fees: what you pay on a $100 sale
These are the published U.S. rates. They can change, so check the official pages before you budget: Stripe’s pricing page and PayPal’s merchant fee schedule, which was last updated on November 4, 2026.
| Payment type | Stripe | PayPal |
|---|---|---|
| Online card (domestic) | 2.9% + 30¢ | 2.99% + 49¢ (standard card payments) |
| Wallet checkout | n/a | 3.49% + 49¢ (PayPal Checkout, Guest Checkout, Venmo) |
| Pay Later | n/a | 4.99% + 49¢ |
| International cards | +1.5% | +1.5% on international commercial transactions |
| Monthly or setup fee | None on standard pricing | None for PayPal Checkout |
Here is the math on a $100 domestic payment, using those published rates:
- Stripe card: 2.9% is $2.90, plus $0.30, so $3.20. You keep $96.80.
- PayPal standard card: 2.99% is $2.99, plus $0.49, so $3.48. You keep $96.52.
- PayPal Checkout: 3.49% is $3.49, plus $0.49, so $3.98. You keep $96.02.
The gap looks small on one sale. It grows with volume. Core Forms worked out that 100 payments of $50 a month cost $175 in Stripe fees and $223.50 in PayPal Checkout fees. That is $48.50 a month, or $582 a year. The fixed 49¢ hurts most on small orders, so a shop selling $15 add-ons feels it more than a firm sending $2,000 invoices.
Fees beyond the headline rate
The headline number is not the whole bill. A few extras to plan for:
- International cards and currency: Stripe adds 1.5% for international cards and, per GoPayhawk’s 2026 breakdown, 1% for currency conversion. Paysight reports PayPal charges up to 4% on most currency conversions.
- Disputes: Stripe charges $15 when a dispute arrives and $15 more if you counter it manually, returned if you win. PayPal lists a $15 standard dispute fee, $30 for high-volume sellers and $20 on some card chargebacks, per Ecommerce Paradise.
- Invoices and bank payments: Stripe adds 0.4% per paid invoice on its Starter plan, according to Nive. For bank (ACH) payments, Ecommerce Paradise lists Stripe at 0.8% capped at $5 and PayPal invoices at 1% capped at $10.
- In person: Stripe Terminal is listed at 2.7% + 5¢, and PayPal card-present and QR payments at 2.29% + 9¢.
- Instant payouts: Both charge 1.5% with a 50¢ minimum for instant transfers.
If you sell through Shopify and use PayPal as a standalone outside gateway, Eightx notes Shopify adds its own surcharge on top, up to 2% on the Basic plan. That is a good example of a cost that never appears on either processor’s fee page.
Checkout and customization
This is where the two differ most, and where your website matters.
Stripe offers a hosted checkout page, an embedded one, Payment Links and customizable form components. Per Ecommerce Paradise, it supports 125+ payment methods and 135+ currencies. Stripe’s own pricing page cites cardholder support in 195+ countries and PCI compliance. PCI is the security standard for handling card data, and using a hosted or embedded form keeps most of that burden off your site.
PayPal gives you a button that sends buyers to PayPal to log in and pay, with PayPal, Venmo, Pay Later or cards as options. Zapier’s comparison calls this off-page checkout “absurdly easy” for buyers and needs no coding, while Stripe’s on-site checkout keeps customers on your pages and is fully brandable, though a little trickier to set up.

For a business whose website is its storefront, that trade-off usually points one way. A branded checkout that looks like the rest of your site feels more trustworthy at the moment of payment. It also lets you control the page where most abandoned carts are lost. The same logic applies if you are weighing platforms: our comparison of Shopify and WooCommerce covers how the store platform affects which payment tools fit.
Subscriptions, invoices and getting paid
If you sell services, memberships or retainers, billing tools matter more than the card rate. Stripe handles subscriptions, invoices and in-person payments under one account. Stripe Billing is priced at 0.7% of Billing volume, per GoPayhawk.
One portability point from Paysight is worth knowing. A subscription built on a PayPal billing agreement only works with PayPal. If that account is ever restricted, those subscribers cannot be moved to another processor. Stripe, by contrast, will export card data to another PCI DSS Level 1 processor, excluding credentials saved through its Link wallet. If recurring revenue is your business, this matters.
Payout timing
Nive reports that Stripe’s first payout usually takes 7 to 14 days, after which U.S. payments settle in about two business days. PayPal keeps money in your PayPal balance, with free standard bank transfers and 1.5% for instant ones. Plan for that first-payout wait when you launch a new site, because the first sales will not reach your bank right away.
Holds, reserves and account closures
This is the part nobody enjoys, and it is the best reason to prepare before launch rather than after.
Both Stripe and PayPal are aggregators, meaning you share their account and risk model instead of holding your own underwritten merchant account. Paysight explains that holds, reserves and closures follow the provider’s policies, and a closure stops all payments at once, including scheduled renewals.
What the published terms say:
- PayPal: It can hold a payment in reserve for up to 21 days from receipt, and account limitations can restrict withdrawals or receiving while it reviews. Business accounts can face rolling or minimum reserves, per ToS Watchdog’s review of the User Agreement.
- Stripe: It keeps a restricted-business list, including categories such as tobacco and e-cigarettes and negative-option marketing with unclear pricing, per Paysight. Either provider can hold part of a balance as a reserve.
The practical protection is mostly boring and entirely within your control:
- Describe what you sell accurately in your account application and on your site.
- Publish clear pricing, refund and cancellation terms. Unclear billing terms are a common trigger for disputes.
- Respond to every dispute with order records, delivery proof and customer messages.
- Keep a second way to take payment ready, so one frozen account does not stop all revenue.
Points 1 and 2 are website work. Your product pages, pricing page and policies are the evidence a processor reads when it reviews your business.
Which one fits your business
Here is the short guide, drawing on NerdWallet’s 2026 comparison and Nive’s verdict.
Choose Stripe if you:
- Sell mainly through your own website
- Want a checkout that matches your branding
- Plan subscriptions, invoices or retainers
- Sell to customers in many countries or currencies
- Want lower fees on typed-in cards
NerdWallet also cites Stripe’s 24/7 live chat support as an advantage.
Choose PayPal if you:
- Have customers who already pay with PayPal or Venmo
- Want a familiar button with minimal setup
- Run a physical shop and want PayPal’s POS hardware, which NerdWallet prices from a $29 first card reader up to a $699 Store Kit Plus
A service business such as a law practice, a consultancy or a contractor sending invoices has a fairly clear answer: Stripe, with invoices as the default. A small online shop selling to a broad consumer audience usually does best with Stripe for cards and a PayPal button as a second option.
Using both
Many small businesses offer both, and it works. Stripe handles cards and any recurring billing, and PayPal gives buyers who prefer it their wallet. Zapier notes the cost: you maintain two integrations, deal with two support teams for disputes, and reconcile more complicated financial records.
To keep that manageable:
- Put Stripe first on the checkout page and the PayPal button second.
- Use one accounting export routine so both feed the same books each month.
- Check each integration after every WordPress or plugin update, since a broken payment plugin means lost sales.
That last point is why many owners put payments inside a monthly maintenance plan rather than hoping nothing breaks.
How to decide in four steps
- Estimate your average order size and monthly volume. Run both fee formulas on your own numbers. Under $50 per order, the fixed fee is the biggest difference.
- List who pays you. Consumers, other businesses, international buyers? Each points to different methods.
- Decide if you bill on a schedule. If yes, Stripe’s subscription and invoice tools, and the ability to move card data later, weigh heavily.
- Tell your web designer before the build. Checkout layout, thank-you pages, tax and shipping rules and policy pages all depend on this choice.
What we think about payments and websites
Most owners treat the payment processor as something to sort out after launch. We think it belongs in the first conversation. The checkout is where your site either earns trust or loses a sale, and it is far easier to design a branded, clear checkout from the start than to patch one in later.
Our approach is to make the technical side understandable for business owners. That means plain explanations of what each choice costs and what it changes on the page, so you can decide with confidence. For most of the businesses we work with, a WordPress site with a card checkout you control, plus a PayPal option for the buyers who want it, is a sound and flexible setup.
We also like sites that are built to last. A payment flow needs care after launch: updates, security checks and content changes keep it running smoothly, which is why we offer ongoing support alongside the build.
Tommy Cosimano
Plan the checkout with your website
A processor is only half of getting paid online. The other half is the site that carries it. I design and build custom WordPress websites for small businesses, startups and nonprofits across the United States, and I keep the process clear and collaborative so you always know what you are paying for.
Our published pricing starts with a Base Website at $875, with Essentials at $1,200, Growth at $2,400 and Premium at $4,800, all one-off. If you want someone to look after plugins, security and content once you launch, Ongoing Maintenance is $100 per month.
If you are launching a store or a service site and want the checkout planned from the start, see our website pricing or get in touch through tcosi.com. If you are a developer integrating a payment API yourself, our guide to staging-first WordPress API integrations covers the safe way to test.
FAQ
How much is the Stripe fee for $100?
On a domestic card payment, Stripe’s published rate of 2.9% + 30¢ comes to $3.20, so you keep $96.80. International cards add 1.5%, and currency conversion adds 1%. Check Stripe’s pricing page for the current rates.
Is Stripe or PayPal cheaper for a small business?
Stripe is cheaper for most online card sales. PayPal Checkout at 3.49% + 49¢ costs more than Stripe’s 2.9% + 30¢ on every payment size. PayPal’s QR code rate of 2.29% + 9¢ can be lower for in-person payments, so your sales channel changes the answer.
Can I use Stripe and PayPal on the same website?
Yes. Many sites offer Stripe for cards and a PayPal button as a second option. You will manage two integrations and two sets of dispute handling, and your bookkeeping needs to combine both. A maintenance plan helps keep both checkouts working after updates.
Which is better for ecommerce?
Stripe suits stores that want a branded checkout, many payment methods and international sales. PayPal adds value as a trusted button for buyers who prefer paying with PayPal or Venmo. Most online stores do best offering Stripe first and PayPal alongside it.
Why would a payment account get frozen?
Both providers can place holds or reserves based on their risk policies, such as high dispute rates, unusual volume or unclear business categories. Clear policies on your site, accurate business descriptions and quick dispute responses reduce the chance of trouble.
Sources
- Stripe: Financial Infrastructure to Grow Your Revenue
- Stripe: Pricing & Fees
- PayPal: What is PayPal and How Does it Work
- PayPal: Merchant and Business Fees
- Ecommerce Paradise: Stripe vs PayPal 2026
- Core Forms: PayPal vs Stripe Fees
- GoPayhawk: GoPayhawk vs. Stripe Fees
- Paysight: Stripe vs PayPal for Ecommerce
- Nive: Stripe vs PayPal Fees and Fit
- Eightx: PayPal for Ecommerce Review
- ToS Watchdog: PayPal User Agreement Review
- NerdWallet: Stripe vs. PayPal
- Zapier: Stripe vs. PayPal



